
“Wow, you’ve put on so much weight since the last time I saw you.” Growing up Asian-Australian, I heard remarks like that from relatives. In my family, a comment about someone’s appearance could pass for a greeting. I suspect some of them would have been surprised to learn it bothered me. We might have had months of news to catch up on, and my weight was the first thing they mentioned.
These days, I am sometimes tempted to reply with an equally blunt observation. Part of me wants the other person to know how it feels to be looked over like that. What I would really like is for them to ask how I have been and give me time to answer.
I was brought up to show respect for my elders, so when an older relative makes a comment like that, I usually let it pass. It can still sting. Taking a breath gives me a moment to acknowledge how I feel before I carry on with the conversation.
What Your First Reaction Can Tell You
When a remark stings, it can be tempting to put yourself on trial. Was it really that bad? Would someone else have laughed? It may help to ask yourself, “Which part of that bothered me?”
With a comment about weight, it might be the assumption that your appearance is open for discussion. Or perhaps what hurt most was seeing everyone at the table turn to look. If it was the attention that embarrassed you, you might prefer to speak to your relative later, when you have some privacy.
Psychologists James Gross and Oliver John studied how people manage and express their emotions. People who regularly kept their feelings from showing tended to report more negative emotion. You can let a comment pass in company and still be honest about how it affected you. Later, with someone you trust, you might say, “Actually, that really bothered me.”
Give Yourself a Moment
One clue that I could use a pause is how pleased I am with the comeback I have in mind. What I find harder to picture is the minute after I say it. Do I want to spend the rest of this visit trading remarks about each other’s appearance?
The UK mental health charity Mind suggests giving yourself time when anger first rises. In conversation, that might mean taking one slow breath before you speak. A few seconds can feel surprisingly long when someone is waiting for you to laugh. You can leave that silence unfilled while you decide whether to say anything.
If you do want to speak up, “That hurt” may be all you need to say. Even if your voice shakes, you have told the person something they might otherwise have missed. You can explain why it hurt later if you want to.
When You Want the Comments to Stop
A relative can be genuinely pleased to see you and choose a poor way to say so. You might simply ask, “How was your trip?” and let the conversation move on. If you would like them to stop mentioning your weight, you could say, “It’s good to see you. I’d rather we didn’t talk about my weight.”
If they say, “I was only joking”, it is easy to get drawn into an argument about whether the joke was funny. You can keep your answer simple. “I understand. I’d still like you to stop.”
Part of setting a boundary with someone you care about is deciding what you will do if the remarks continue. That might mean ending the call or finding someone else to talk to at lunch. You can follow through even if your relative thinks you are making a fuss.
Growing Up with Racist Remarks
The remarks that hurt me most growing up were the racist ones. In Australia in the 1980s and 1990s, other kids sometimes shouted racial slurs at me. A whole group might tell me how much they disliked Chinese or Vietnamese people, or Asian people generally. They could pick me out on sight and decide I was someone they despised. They didn’t even have to know my name.
I wouldn’t tell my younger self to take that less personally. I was the person they were shouting at. What I would have liked to hear from someone beside me was, “You belong here as much as any of them do.”
I encounter that kind of abuse less often these days, and it hurts less when I do. I can only guess what leads someone to shout abuse at a stranger. They know very little about me, and their opinion carries less weight than it once did. Sometimes a nasty encounter even gives me an extra push to get on with something I care about. The work I enjoy and the people I love are part of my life long after that stranger’s words have faded.
Saying “That’s racist” can matter to someone else who heard the remark and wondered if anyone would speak up. When a group is looking for a confrontation, getting away safely may matter most. However you respond, the responsibility for the abuse stays with the people who chose to shout it.
When a Stranger Comments Online
You share something you made or enjoyed, and someone writes, “Nobody cares.” It can feel worse knowing that anyone who sees your post can read that comment too. Before long you might wonder whether you should have shared it at all.
It helps to take a second look at the word “nobody”. One person wrote that comment. How would they know what everyone else thinks? Perhaps you posted something because a particular friend would get a laugh out of it. It would be a shame to take it down before that friend has even seen it.
You might leave a dismissive comment unanswered, mute the account or turn off notifications and get on with your evening. If things go further and someone repeatedly targets you or makes a threat, it may be worth keeping a record before blocking the account. Australia’s eSafety Commissioner suggests saving details such as a screenshot and a link to the post in case you decide to report it.
If the Words Come to You Later
Some of the clearest replies occur to us on the way home. If you laughed along because you felt awkward, you can revisit the moment in private. “I know I laughed at lunch, but I felt embarrassed when you mentioned my weight in front of everyone.” Someone who cares about you may be glad to know how different it felt on your side of the table.
If you said something hurtful in return, you can still make amends for what you said and ask for the comments to stop. “I’m sorry I made that dig about your appearance. It was unkind. I’d like us to leave each other’s weight out of the conversation.” You can mean both the apology and the request.
The Conversation I Would Rather Have
When I think about those family greetings, I keep coming back to how much else there was to talk about. What has been happening at home? What has made them laugh lately? I would happily spend a meal hearing the long version of either answer.
If an older relative opens with a comment about my weight, I can pull up a chair and ask, “How have you been?” I can wish they had greeted me differently and still be glad I stayed to hear the answer.